What to Say When a Prospect Says “Send Me an Email”

Sometimes it’s a brush-off and sometimes it’s a real request. A couple of quick questions will tell you which.

Scott Henkin
Scott Henkin Founder, Tek & Tel
4 min read
Cold Calling

“Just send me an email” might be the most common response on a cold call. Many reps hear it, say “sure,” send a generic overview and never hear back. With a little care, you can turn this moment into a real next step.

01Figure out what they actually mean

Sometimes the prospect is genuinely busy and wants to read something later. Other times it’s a polite way to end the call. You can find out with one short question before you hang up.

“Happy to. So I send something useful, what’s the main thing you’d want to know?”
“Sure. Is this something you’re looking at now, or more for later in the year?”
“Will do. Are you the right person for this, or should I copy someone else?”

If they answer with something specific, you have a real lead and a reason to follow up. If they dodge every question, that tells you something too.

02Send the email right away

Send it within the hour, while the call is still fresh. Reference the conversation in the subject line so it doesn’t look like another cold email. Keep it short: what they asked about, a sentence or two on how you help, and one simple next step.

A simple structure
Thanks for the call. You mentioned [their priority]. Here’s a quick summary of how we handle that for companies like yours. Would a 20-minute call next Tuesday or Wednesday be worth it?

03Put a follow-up on the calendar

Before you end the call, ask: “If I send that today, would it be OK to call you Thursday to see if it’s worth a conversation?” Most people will agree, and now your next call isn’t cold.

Want help putting this into practice?
We’ll look at your targeting, channels and follow-up on a free 30-minute call.
Book a Strategy Call →

04Don’t take it personally

Even when it is a brush-off, it’s rarely about you. The prospect was busy and you caught them at a bad time. Send the email, follow up as promised and let the sequence do its work.

Scott Henkin
Written by Scott Henkin, Founder of Tek & Tel
Scott brings more than 20 years of sales experience to helping businesses build stronger pipelines through appointment setting, sales development, LinkedIn outreach, cold email and lead generation.

Ready for more qualified meetings?

Book a free strategy call and we’ll show you where your next opportunities are likely to come from.

Book a Strategy Call → Free 30-minute call · No obligation